Af3 +1 Or Calmecac Trousers

Calmecac would win if you have capped acc. That said, etoile +2 with saber dance augment should be your primary goal if u want to DD or solo DNC. The extra 5% DA and acc is awesome. Thaumas are for saber dance down only. Etoile +2 don't cost much either assuming u can get the drop; maybe 3k~ per forgotten journey on my server, could fully upgrade for 150k.

I know I only barely answered the question but, ya...hope it did help.

I thought Thaumas won for all situations. More acc, way more att and more STR, with more haste so you can lighten up some pieces.

With saber up then etoile essentially add 5% DA, and as has already been said, dnc doesnt suffer for acc. Saber down then thaumas yes.

Refer you to sylow's thread http://www.ffxiah.com/forum/topic/27566/the-last-dance-gearing-paradigms-for-a-new-age/

Is from that thread. Sometimes the OPs don't get updated, but yeah. He also doesn't have any skadi+1 on the OP, but he has a ton of it with his Terp in his personal sets.