I have some curious questions poking around, and it may be due to the limited info the ffxivpro and other sites have.
Currently, ALL foods made only give +5 in two attributes, and all raw mats give either +5 or +3 to stats.
Orange juice and Pineapple juice are the same, boiled eggs and dodo omlettes are the same.
The way I see it is that three things could be possible: 1st is optimal ranks for food cause the persons testing the food to give them +5s +3s ect... for each foods. 2nd possibly is after you pass the optimal rank for the food, it no longer gives you the benefits (and may be why people do not receive +craftsmanship to boiled eggs, and why there are multiple foods giving the same stats) or lastly the information given are just placeholders and I am freaking out over nothing.
If anyone can post any helpful information or testing it will be greatly appreciated.